http://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2010/04/home-tax-credit-costly-failure.html When you read this article, you can easily come to the conclusion that the Home Buyer Tax Credit cost too much and did not accomplish what it was intended to do. Even if I agreed with the statements made in this article (which I don't), the writer leaves out the other side of the home buying story. Even if 1 out of 4 or 5 buyers would have bought anyway, that is still 20-25% more which is huge when you think how miserable the housing market had been. I have a hard time with that stat especially as I look at the buyers our agents have been working with over these last two weeks. Many are looking to buy knowing 4/30 is coming and they don't want to miss out on the $8,000 1st time buyer or the $6,500 move up buyer credit. That said, the other aspect of this story is the many people who were put to work because these 20-25% of home buyers chose to buy. Here are some who have benefitted just to name a few. Real Estate Attorneys and their staff, lenders and their staff, increased city and county tax revenues, builders and local sub-contractors. local movers who moved the seller and the buyers from and into their new homes, local merchants to whom home buyers went to buy tv's, window treatments, appliances, etc. Unlike the bank bailouts, this stimulus money trickled down to help the local (Charlottesville and surrounding counties in VA) economy which means the dollars spent made a difference to many of our neighbors and friends.